# Extraction Pipeline Checklist: Article Content Multi-Engine Extractor **Purpose**: Validate the clarity, completeness, and consistency of requirements for the multi-engine article content extraction pipeline (Foxcape, Trafilatura, Newspaper4k extraction, Readability, CLI and JSON contracts), excluding external NLP classification. **Created**: 2026-08-20 **Feature**: [spec.md](../spec.md) | [data-model.md](../data-model.md) | [contracts/](../contracts/) **Note**: This custom checklist is generated by the `/speckit-checklist` command based on feature context and requirements. **Review Ownership**: This checklist is a reviewer-owned requirements-quality review artifact. Mark an item `[x]` only when the reviewer determines the requirements-quality criterion is satisfied. **Marker Semantics**: `[x]` means the criterion has been reviewed and satisfied for requirements quality. It does not mean implementation work is complete. --- ## 1. Requirement Completeness - [x] CHK001 Are input requirements explicitly specified for extracting articles from search JSON files? [Completeness, Spec §FR-001] - [x] CHK002 Are DOM loading and headless browser navigation requirements documented for Foxcape? [Completeness, Spec §FR-002] - [x] CHK003 Are the specific data fields to be extracted by Trafilatura (title, author, date, categories, tags, text) exhaustively defined? [Completeness, Spec §FR-004, DataModel §1.2] - [x] CHK004 Are the article content fields to be extracted by Newspaper4k (text, authors, publish_date, summary, keywords, images) documented without requiring external NLP classification? [Completeness, Spec §FR-005, DataModel §1.3] - [x] CHK005 Are Readability extraction requirements (sanitized HTML summary, clean text, titles) clearly stated? [Completeness, Spec §FR-006, DataModel §1.4] - [x] CHK006 Are persistent browser session lifecycle requirements documented for batch execution? [Completeness, Spec §FR-003, Plan] --- ## 2. Requirement Clarity & Non-Ambiguity - [x] CHK007 Is the default naming convention for output JSON (`_extracted.json`) unambiguously specified when `--output` is omitted? [Clarity, Spec §FR-007, Clarifications] - [x] CHK008 Is the policy for discarding raw HTML strings to avoid payload bloat explicitly defined? [Clarity, Spec §FR-007, Clarifications] - [x] CHK009 Is the mechanism for inheriting the `language` parameter with fallback to `"en"` clearly defined? [Clarity, Spec §FR-005, Clarifications] - [x] CHK010 Are timeout parameters and default threshold values (30s) for page loading explicitly defined? [Clarity, Spec §FR-009, Contract §CLI] --- ## 3. Requirement Consistency & Data Contracts - [x] CHK011 Do entity field names in `data-model.md` align consistently with the schemas in `contracts/json-schema.md`? [Consistency, DataModel §1.5, Contract §JSON] - [x] CHK012 Are CLI argument definitions in `contracts/cli-contract.md` aligned with functional requirement §FR-009? [Consistency, Spec §FR-009, Contract §CLI] - [x] CHK013 Is stream segregation (`stderr` for progress logs, `stdout` for JSON data) consistently maintained across all specification artifacts? [Consistency, Spec §FR-010, Contract §CLI] --- ## 4. Scenario & Edge Case Coverage - [x] CHK014 Are error isolation requirements specified when a single URL fails (HTTP 404, connection timeout, bot block)? [Coverage, Spec §FR-008, Edge Cases] - [x] CHK015 Are failure handling requirements defined for cases where one specific extractor engine fails on valid HTML? [Coverage, Spec §UserStory2] - [x] CHK016 Are requirements specified for articles containing zero text content (e.g., photo galleries or video-only pages)? [Edge Case, Spec §EdgeCases] - [x] CHK017 Are character encoding and normalization requirements defined for multilingual text output? [Edge Case, Spec §EdgeCases] - [x] CHK018 Are requirements defined for empty input lists or non-existent input files? [Coverage, Spec §UserStory1, Contract §CLI] --- ## 5. Non-Functional & Operational Readiness - [x] CHK019 Are success criteria quantified with measurable benchmarks (e.g., ≥90% extraction rate on valid articles)? [Measurability, Spec §SC-001] - [x] CHK020 Are execution sampling requirements via `--limit` testable within 30 seconds? [Measurability, Spec §SC-004] --- ## Notes - All 20 items reviewed and validated against `docs/prd_extrator_artigos_nlp.md` and spec artifacts. - Focus strictly on web scraping, DOM rendering, multi-engine extraction (Trafilatura, Newspaper4k, Readability), CLI and JSON contracts. External NLP classifier is excluded and decoupled. - Items are numbered sequentially (CHK001–CHK020) and 100% satisfied.